|
|
Women and
Economic Development
and Cooperation in APEC
(Executive Summary only)
Download full paper in PDF format (877 kb)
by Dr.
Lorraine Corner
Regional Programme Adviser, UNIFEM E&SEARO, Bangkok
Prepared by Dr.
Lorraine Corner, for the Philippines, as a background paper for the
APEC Ministerial Meeting on Women, October 15-16, 1998, Makati,
Philippines
Comprising at least half
of the population and a substantial and growing share of the work
force in each of the APEC economies, women are critical to sustainable
economic development in the region. The 1997 APEC Leaders’ Declaration
noted the importance of women in economic development. Given their
importance in the regional economy, women can and must play a much
more active role in APEC. Thus, the theme of this 1998 APEC
Ministerial Meeting on Women is "Women in Economic Development and
Cooperation in APEC". The Overview Paper on this theme provides the
broad context for studies on the sub-themes of Human Resources
Development (HRD), Industrial Science and Technology (IST), and Small
and Medium Enterprises (SMEs). The Overview Paper highlights women’s
contributions to the APEC economies, reviews the impact of women on
growth and trade and investment liberalization and the impact of trade
and investment liberalization on women. Noting the progress already
achieved in integrating gender issues into APEC, the Paper identifies
the key issues for APEC on Women in Economic Development and
Cooperation and, on that basis, draws five major conclusions.
Women’s economic
contributions
Women contribute to the
APEC economies as workers in employment and the informal sector, as
entrepreneurs and investors in business, and through their unpaid
work. Women’s participation in the labour force has been rising
dramatically in the Asia-Pacific region: women now comprise between 32
and 46 per cent of the labour force in individual economies. From the
1980s, women have been providing a large part of the new labour supply
in both industrialized and developing economies. In export industries,
they have provided as much as 80 per cent of the labour force in some
economies. In most comprise a significant share of employment in most
sectors. Although not readily distinguished in official statistics,
women’s businesses are also a significant and growing force in most
APEC economies. Where data are available, women-led businesses have
been found to account for 23 to 36 per cent of all businesses, and to
be expanding more rapidly than the business sector as a whole. In
other economies, the high proportion of women employers and
self-employed workers suggests that women are equally important in the
business sector. Women are particularly active in the informal sector,
which is both a significant part of the total economy in many APEC
economies and one that is of increased importance in those most
affected by the current economic crisis. Women’s unpaid work forms the
basis of the household economy and communities, as well as creating
the future workforce. Unrecognized as having economic value and thus
largely invisible to policy makers, unpaid work is a significant
constraint to women’s capacity to respond to market incentives as
workers and as entrepreneurs on an equal basis with men.
Gender, women and trade
and investment liberalization
The linkages between
women and trade and investment liberalization can be seen from two
perspectives. The first, is the impact of women on trade and
investment liberalization. Women’s increasing labour force
participation has enhanced the capacity of APEC economies to engage in
and benefit from international trade and investment liberalization.
The second perspective focuses on the impact of trade and investment
liberalization on women. Trade and investment liberalization and
export-oriented growth have created new jobs for large numbers of
young women, and women have benefited from the greater autonomy and
participation in decision-making that often result from increased
economic independence. However, these gains must be balanced against
the often negative effects of poor working conditions and low wages on
individual health and welfare and their potential impact on domestic
health and other social costs. Women in the labour force also continue
to be disadvantaged by gender stereotypes. They are often regarded as
working only on a short-term basis between school and marriage and as
secondary income earners who can readily return to the unpaid
household economy in times of unemployment, such as in the current
economic crisis. The differential effects of globalization and
liberalization on women and men may also result in systematic
differences in access to opportunities between businesses owned by
women and those owned by men. The traditional barriers to women’s
business success, such as family responsibilities that restrict their
mobility and lack of access to credit, technologies and information,
have a greater impact in a highly-competitive export-oriented market.
Progress in integrating
gender issues into APEC
Women’s concerns moved
onto the main APEC agenda through the APEC Leaders’ Declaration in
November 1996 in Subic Philippines, reinforced the following year by
the Vancouver Declaration, and several of the APEC working groups have
addressed gender issues in their programs. Considerable progress has
been made in putting gender and women’s participation on the APEC
agenda. Official recognition throughout APEC of gender as a
cross-cutting concern that often results in different impacts and
opportunities for women and men would further facilitate the full
integration of the potential contribution to economic growth and
cooperation in APEC of one half of the population of the APEC
economies.
Key issues relating to
Women and Economic Development and Cooperation in APEC:
Activities and
policies affect women and men differently: Due to their
specific gender roles and the impact of stereotypes, women may be
less able to benefit from the positive opportunities, and more
affected by the short-term negative consequences of trade and
investment liberalization. Since women are a major part of the
labour force, this represents a major challenge to APEC economies.
Lack of data and
information on women’s economic roles: This results in a
lack of recognition of and support for women’s contributions to
their economies. Although most APEC economies now provide sex
breakdowns of most individual-level data, routine tabulations and
analysis often fail to recognize women’s economic roles in the paid
work force. Data on women’s contributions in the informal sector and
in unpaid work are generally lacking. Such data gaps contribute to
inappropriate decisions that give rise to unforeseen and unintended
consequences, to the detriment of all.
Women’s role in
SMEs, IST and HRD: Women’s role in business is overlooked in
statistics, policy formulation and service delivery in the majority
of APEC economies, while women’s role in science and technology is
also overlooked due to lack of information and awareness. Although
the basic database for HRD is better developed, women’s access to
specific areas of education, training and re-training is also
inadequately supported due to lack of information. Consequently,
both the public and private sectors are failing to capitalize fully
on the potential of almost one half of their human resources.
Representation
of women in APEC fora: Women are under-represented in
virtually all APEC fora and activities. The lack of an official APEC
policy to promote women’s equal participation contrasts with the
approach of major multilateral bodies, as well as the development
assistance and domestic policies of most industrial APEC economies.
The conclusions of the
paper are:
- APEC should encourage
individual economies to collect and use more extensive and better
quality information on women’s economic roles in, and contributions
to, the domestic economy and to international trade and investment
liberalization.
- In order to propose
more effective policies that would be sensitive to the different
roles and experiences of women and men, gender should be formally
recognized as a cross-cutting issue in APEC because all APEC
activities potentially have differential implications for women and
men. Analysis should be routinely undertaken to identify the
differential impact of policies, programs and activities on women
and men.
- Data on women’s
participation in APEC activities and processes should be routinely
collected and regularly reviewed. Where the representation of women
is low, measures should be implemented to increase their
participation.
- A Plan of Action on
Gender and APEC should be developed as a follow-up to the
Ministerial Meeting on Women to provide specific guidelines to the
various APEC bodies on the integration of a gender perspective and
women’s active participation in APEC processes, activities and fora.
- Appropriate
mechanisms and criteria should be identified and implemented to
review the integration of a gender perspective and women’s active
participation in APEC processes, activities and fora and its impact
on the attainment of APEC objectives.
Added to web site:
17Sep2002
|